Thursday, February 17, 2011

For Anna

In response to Anna's recent post, and after a phone conversation with her earlier today, I am posting a review of my latest reads, totaling just under 3,000 pages. I am not sure what started the reading of this string of presidential biographies, but it has been most enjoyable and enlightening. I have to say that I rate them all as excellent and worthy of the time it took to plow through them.


Just minutes ago, I finished Pulitzer-Prize-winning American Lion by Newsweek editor Jon Meacham. I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I had no idea who Jackson was or how important he was in shaping the power of the presidency. Like each of the men (with the exception of Lincoln -- who was near perfect) about whom I have read, Jackson had his faults, but he also had an undeniable force of will and ferocity that saved the Union and set the presidency at the heart of the government.


This was my second time through John Adams by David McCullough, and as a result of old age or a brain like a sieve (which is not attributable to old age: it was ever thus), it was all new to me and I thoroughly enjoyed it again this time. I was motivated by the Washington biography to read it again. Chernow's biography was not always kind to Adams, as it rightly should not have been. Adams had his problems. Although, Anna, he was not a racist.


Washington, by Ron Chernow was fascinating. I have been jaded since grade school by the mythical Washington and it was wonderful to meet the real man. Far from the god depicted in the dome of the capitol at Washington D.C., he was a very human man who was blessed to establish and hold together a fragile Union that was preserved so tenaciously by Adams, Jackson, and Lincoln.


The Abraham Lincoln biography, Team of Rivals by Doris Kearns Goodwin is, to me, the best book of the lot, as is the man himself: he was essentially flawless in my book. What a genuinely good person and masterful politician he was. Kris said (and I concur) that he must have been placed by the hand of God. And, Anna, although he was not a racist of the Jefferson and Jackson mold, it took him a while to arrive at the idea of total emancipation. I liked this book best of all.


My reading of The River of Doubt by Candice Millard was unrelated to the other biographies. Kris simply thought I would enjoy it, which I did, and it happened to be the first in the string. The story is a small slice of Theodore Roosevelt's life, not a complete biography. But what a tasty slice it was! Kris thinks that men will like it better than women because it is a rough-and-tumble story of Roosevelt's exploration and mapping of the Rio da Dúvida (River of Doubt), renamed Rio Roosevelt, in Brazil. The river is one of the headwaters of the Amazon and was filled with dangers and difficulties that, in a way, killed Roosevelt. Having traveled up the Amazon and Rio Negro with Kris and Phillip, and having a very personal interest in Brazil, I was quickly hooked. I passed the book on to Phillip who also enjoyed it. I want to know how well Bill liked the more complete biography of TR that he read recently.

In all these reads, one thing has become quite clear to me: nothing has changed in American politics since the time of Washington. Partisan politics, so hated by Adams, has been a persistent fact of life, and yellow journalism practiced so freely today has always been with us. Presidents have always been hated by many and loved by the rest. It makes me feel much calmer about the political climate today: this too will pass and the Union and our "freedoms" will not disappear even though folks with a predilection for tea wouldn't stand for that notion.

Another thing that has been pervasive in these reads is that Thomas Jefferson was a bit of a noodle. Does anyone know of a well-written biography of TJ?

Well, I am off to read McCullough's Truman, with a possible break to read Bill Bryson's At Home.

I will post my current read, as always, at the top of the blog.

OXO

D.

5 comments:

Carrie B. said...

How far down on the list is "Decision Points?" ;) (I guess it doesn't quite fit the genre of books you listed here, as it is written by the actual president). Can't wait to read them all. Thanks for the suggestions!

Anna said...

Wahoo. Thanks for the post. So sad I bought the wrong Washington biography. Oh well, I will read the one I bought and the one you suggested. And I have little patience for Jefferson.
AND, I agree with what you have to say about politics ever being thus. I found it quite comforting to know that nothing much has changed. Although in Lincoln's time the biography made it seem that people were much more engaged in the process than they are now. I feel like today the majority of people are more in tune with the Kardashian's than politics.

David and Kris Taylor said...

Carrie: It might be amusing to see what GWB thinks about himself.

D.

Courtney said...

Hear, hear. I LOVED John Adams and Team of Rivals and River of Doubt. I'm interested in the Truman biography, you'll have to let us know how it goes.

Bill Hastings said...

Here, here on "Team of Rivals" and "John Adams"! Bought Chernow but haven't read it yet. Also, "Decision Points." I'll do a post on TR.